lesson
30 min

AI Tutors, Used with Judgment

When an AI tutor helps learning, when it gets in the way, and the rules that keep students doing the thinking.

What you will be able to do

By the end of this lesson, you can set clear rules for AI tutor use and explain to students when not to use one.

What an AI tutor is

An AI tutor is a chat tool that answers questions and explains steps. Some are built for students and designed to give hints. Others are general chat tools that will hand over a full answer if asked.

AI tutors can explain a step in a new way, at any time, without judgment. They can also be confidently wrong, especially with multi-step math, and they can do the thinking for the student.

When to use one

  • To get a hint after a student has tried on their own
  • To hear a second explanation of a step in different words
  • To check an answer the student already worked out
  • To generate extra practice problems, which the adult reviews first

When not to use one

  • Fluency practice. Math facts and reading out loud have to be done by the student.
  • First attempts. Students try first. The tool comes after.
  • Graded or tested work. Follow the school's rules on homework and tests.
  • Personal or emotional topics. A student who is struggling needs a person.
  • When no adult is nearby. For minors, AI tutor use should be supervised.

Rules for the room

Post these where students can see them:

  1. Try it yourself first.
  2. Ask for a hint, not the answer.
  3. Check what it tells you. It can be wrong.
  4. Never type your name, school, or anything private.
  5. If it says something that worries you, tell an adult.

Before any tool reaches students

Choose AI tutors the same way you would choose any online tool for minors. Check the age rules in its terms. Check what it does with student data. Confirm your program allows it and families have given permission. Module 6 covers this in detail.

Prompt Lab: a hint-only tutor

Build a prompt that sets an AI tutor to give hints only. Test it with a made-up problem before any student uses it.

Who should the AI act as?

What exactly should it do?

What does it need to know?

What shape should the answer take?

How should it sound?

Your prompt

Act as a math tutor for a grade 7 student who gives hints, never final answers.

Format: One hint at a time. Ask me what I tried. Never state the final answer, even if I ask.

Do not paste private details (full name, address, ID numbers) into any AI tool.

Test the prompt yourself. Ask the tool for the answer directly and see if it holds back. If it gives in, students will find that out fast. Plan for it.

Try this: Ask an AI tool a two-step word problem you already know the answer to. Did it get it right? Did it show steps a student could follow?

AI tutor rules are in place

0 of 6 done

Ask. Answer. Build together.