Automate, Assist, or Abstain
Use five questions to decide if a task should be fully automated, partly automated, or left to people.
Objective
By the end of this lesson, you can sort any task into automate, assist, or abstain, and explain your reason.
Two kinds of work
Administrative work follows rules. Logging a form into a sheet, sending a reminder, or making a weekly report are examples. The inputs are predictable. "Done" is easy to define.
Creative and relationship work explores options. Writing a grant story, designing a flyer, or calming an upset customer are examples. Quality depends on taste and care. People disagree about what "good" looks like.
Treat them the same and you get one of two failures. Your admin automations break on odd cases, or your creative work starts to sound like a robot.
The five questions
For any task, ask:
- How variable are the inputs? Do requests look the same each time?
- How bad is a mistake? Is it a typo, or is it a family missing a food box?
- Can you define "done"? Could a new volunteer check it with a list?
- How often does it happen? Daily tasks pay back faster than yearly ones.
- Can a mistake be undone? A wrong spreadsheet row is easy to fix. A sent email is not.
The three answers
| Answer | When | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Automate | Inputs are steady, risk is low, done is clear, it happens often, mistakes can be undone | Copy each new volunteer sign-up into a sheet and send a confirmation |
| Assist | It needs judgment, but has repeat steps around it | AI drafts a reply to a catering request. A person reads and edits it before it goes out |
| Abstain | Rare, high-stakes, unclear, or about people's safety | Deciding which family gets emergency rent help. Replying to a crisis message |
Abstain does not mean "never." It often means "fix the process first." If nobody agrees on the steps, an automation cannot follow them.
A local example
An East Side youth soccer league runs on volunteers. Look at three of its tasks:
- Sending game-day reminders to parents. Steady inputs, low risk, weekly. Automate.
- Writing the season recap for the newsletter. Needs voice and care, but AI could pull scores into a first draft. Assist.
- Handling a report that a coach acted unsafe. High stakes, involves minors, needs a trained adult. Abstain. Always.
Quiz: Module 1 check: judgment first
Go deeper: Automating Administrative Workflows vs. Creative Workflows by Dom Davis, Temerarii Media.