lesson
25 min

When Not to Automate

Learn the warning signs that a task should stay human, even when automation is possible.

Objective

By the end of this lesson, you can name five warning signs that a task should not be automated, and explain your call to a partner.

Possible is not the same as wise

Almost anything can be automated now. That does not mean it should be. A good automation builder says no often. Saying no, with a clear reason, is a professional skill.

Five warning signs

1. A person's safety, health, housing, or freedom is at stake. Decisions about who gets help, who gets reported, or who gets turned away need trained people. An automation cannot weigh someone's whole situation.

2. The relationship is the point. A pastor's note to a grieving family. A coach's call to a parent after a hard game. Automating these tells people they are not worth a person's time.

3. The process is broken or unclear. If staff do not agree on the steps, automation locks in confusion.

4. Mistakes cannot be undone. Mass texts, public posts, and payments cannot be pulled back. Add a human approval step or do not automate.

5. Nobody will own it. If no one will watch the alerts and fix it, it will break and stay broken. A broken automation is worse than none, because people think it is working.

Who carries the risk?

Ask who is hurt when the automation is wrong. Often it is not the business owner. It is a customer, a client, or a kid.

A missed reminder for a haircut is a small problem. A missed reply to a family asking a food pantry for help is a large problem. Hold automations that touch people with less power to a higher standard.

A local example: two requests at a food pantry

An East Side food pantry asked a learner to automate its inbox.

  • Volunteer shift reminders: automated. Low risk, steady, easy to fix.
  • Replies to families asking for emergency food: not automated. The learner set up an alert so a staff member sees every request within the hour. A person writes back.

The pantry got faster at both. Only one was automated.

Automation and jobs

Automation can change someone's job. Be honest about it. Talk to the people who do the work before you build. The goal in this course is to remove busywork, so people can spend time on work that needs a person. If an automation would cut someone's hours without their knowledge, stop and talk to your partner and your coach.

Quiz: Should this be automated?

  1. 01A church wants an automated text sent to families when a member passes away. What is the best call?

    Choose one.

  2. 02The owner wants an automation but says nobody has time to check alerts. What do you do?

    Choose one.

Reflection

Private. Saved only in this browser. No one else can see it.