lesson
30 min

Test Before You Spend

Turn one brief into two ideas, test them cheaply, and choose with evidence.

Objective

By the end of this lesson, you can turn one brief into two different ideas, test them cheaply, and choose one with evidence instead of opinion.

Make more than one idea

The first idea is rarely the best one. Push for at least three, then narrow to two. Some ways to get there:

  • Flip it. What if we said the opposite?
  • Show, don't tell. What would the message look like as a single picture?
  • Change the speaker. What if a customer said it instead of the organization?
  • Shrink it. Say it in five words.

Test cheaply

You do not need a big budget to test. You need two versions and a fair way to compare them.

TestHow it works
Hallway testShow both versions to ten people from the audience. Ask which one they would act on and why.
Two flyersPrint two versions with different phone numbers, codes, or QR links. Count responses.
Two postsPost two versions on different days. Compare saves, shares, and messages, not just likes.

Change only one thing at a time. If you change the picture and the headline, you will not know which one made the difference.

A worked example

Picture one summer meals site that wants more families to come.

  • Idea A: "Free meals for kids this summer." Plain and clear.
  • Idea B: "Summer break shouldn't mean an empty lunch box." Uses the insight.

They print both on flyers with different text-message keywords. After two weeks, they count which keyword got more texts. They pick the winner and keep testing the next thing, like the photo.

That is the method. The real numbers will depend on your program. Report what you measured, and never round up.

Ideas must fit the channel

An idea has to work where people will see it. A long story fits a video. It does not fit a bus bench. Before you pick a winner, check that the idea still works in every channel on the brief.

When not to test

  • When there is a safety or legal message. Do not test two versions of a recall or a health warning. Use the clearest version and get it out.
  • When the test would mislead people. Never test a fake offer or a promise the organization cannot keep.
  • When the sample is too small to mean anything. Three responses vs. two is not a winner. Say "too close to call."

Module 4 quiz

Quiz: Module 4 check: creative conception

  1. 01Which one is an insight?

    Choose one.

  2. 02What does 'single-minded' mean in a creative brief?

    Choose one.

  3. 03Two flyers differ in both the photo and the headline. One gets more responses. What can you conclude?

    Choose one.

  4. 04What should never go in a creative brief that gets shared with vendors?

    Choose one.

  5. 05When should you skip A/B testing? Choose all that apply.

    Choose all that apply.

Go deeper: Creative Conception: From Blank Page to Buy-In

Ask. Answer. Build together.