Nonprofit, PBC, or LLC?
Compare three common legal structures, and see why a nonprofit might own a public benefit company.
Your objective
By the end of this lesson, you can compare a nonprofit, a public benefit corporation, and an LLC, and explain the structure Community Incubator uses.
This lesson teaches general ideas. Rules differ by state. It is not legal or tax advice.
Why structure matters
Your legal structure decides who owns the organization, who controls it, how it is taxed, and what money it can accept. Some funders only give to nonprofits. Some contracts are easier for companies. The structure should fit the work.
Three common structures
| Nonprofit (501(c)(3)) | Public benefit corporation (PBC) | LLC | |
|---|---|---|---|
| What it is | An organization formed for a charitable or educational purpose | A for-profit company that must also pursue a stated public benefit | A flexible business with owners called members |
| Owners | No owners. A board governs it for the public. | Shareholders | Members |
| Taxes | Usually exempt from federal income tax. Donors can often deduct gifts. | Taxed like a regular corporation | Profits usually pass through to members' personal taxes |
| Can it accept grants? | Yes. Most foundation and many government grants require it. | Fewer grants. Can win contracts and raise investment. | Fewer grants. Can win contracts. |
| Where profit goes | Must stay in the mission. Nobody takes it home. | Can go to shareholders, but leaders must weigh the public benefit too. | To members |
| Public reporting | Form 990 is public | Many states require a benefit report | Little public reporting |
What "public benefit" means
A benefit corporation or public benefit corporation is a company whose leaders must balance making money with a specific public good written in its founding papers. Maryland passed the first benefit corporation law in 2010. Delaware, where many U.S. companies are formed, added public benefit corporations in 2013. Kickstarter and Warby Parker are examples of PBCs.
A nonprofit that owns a company
Some organizations use both. A nonprofit creates or owns a company. The nonprofit keeps control of the mission. The company does work that fits a business better.
The structure Community Incubator uses
Community Incubator is a nonprofit that owns a public benefit company. Each part does the work it is best suited for:
- The nonprofit wins grants and donations. It sets the mission and keeps control.
- The public benefit company wins government contracts, ideally state- and locally-funded after-school programs that tutor students and teach these skills.
- The goal for both: free education for people in underserved communities.
Common reasons organizations choose this kind of setup:
- Fit for the money. Foundations often require a nonprofit. Some agencies and partners find it simpler to contract with a company.
- Clean books. Business-like income can create tax questions for a nonprofit (the IRS calls it unrelated business income). A separate company keeps it apart.
- Risk. Problems in one part are less likely to sink the other.
- Mission lock. The company's public benefit is written into its founding papers, and the nonprofit owns it.
When not to build two entities
Two organizations means two sets of books, two tax filings, more legal work, and clear rules for how they deal with each other. A new program almost never needs both. Start with the one structure that fits your first source of money. Add a second only when there is a clear reason, and with a lawyer and an accountant.
Reflection
Module 7 Check
Quiz: Module 7: Contracts, IP, and Structures
Discussion
Ask. Answer. Build together.
Loading…