lesson
25 min

When Not to Automate

Keep people in charge of decisions about people, and see what happens when automation goes wrong at scale.

What you will learn

By the end of this lesson, you can identify which steps in a workflow must stay with a person, and explain why.

Automation repeats mistakes fast

A person who makes a mistake makes it once. An automated workflow with a mistake makes it every time it runs, often without anyone noticing. Speed is the point of automation. It is also the risk.

A national example

Keep a person in the loop

Human in the loop means a person reviews or approves a step before it takes effect. Use it for:

  • Decisions about people: who qualifies, who gets flagged, who gets removed.
  • Messages that carry bad news: a denial, a warning, a missed payment.
  • Anything involving a child's safety or records.
  • Anything you cannot easily undo.

Automation can still help in these cases. It can gather the information and prepare a draft. A person makes the call.

Signs a task should stay human

SignExample
It needs care or contextCalling a family whose student stopped coming
The rules have many exceptionsWaiving a requirement for a special situation
A wrong result causes real harmCutting off services
It builds trustA thank-you call to a long-time volunteer

Creative work is different

Admin work (reminders, data entry, reports) is often a good fit for automation. Creative and relationship work (writing to a donor, mentoring a student) usually is not. Automation can handle the setup so people have more time for the human part.

Go deeper: Automating Administrative Workflows vs. Creative Workflows

Quiz: Module 4 Quiz: Automated Workflows

  1. 01What are the three parts of a workflow?

    Choose one.

  2. 02Which is the best first workflow to automate?

    Choose one.

  3. 03Why does every workflow need a failure alert?

    Choose one.

  4. 04What does the MiDAS case show?

    Choose one.

  5. 05Which steps should keep a human in the loop? Choose all that apply.

    Choose all that apply.

Ask. Answer. Build together.