lesson
20 min

Judgment Before Pixels

When design is the wrong answer, and how to spot design that tricks or harms people.

What you will learn in this lesson

You will learn three questions to ask before you design anything. You will also learn to spot dark patterns, which are designs that trick people.

Not every problem needs an app

Designers like to make screens. That is a risk. If all you have is Figma, every problem looks like a missing app.

Ask these three questions first:

  1. Is it a design problem at all? Some problems are about staffing, money, trust, or policy. A new screen won't fix a food pantry that has no volunteers on Tuesdays.
  2. Who gets left out? An online-only fix can shut out people without data plans, older adults, or people who read English as a second language.
  3. What happens when it fails? If the app goes down, can people still get help?

Example: the community garden waitlist

A community garden on the South Side has a waitlist for plots. The list lives in a notebook. People ask, "Can you build us an app?"

After a few conversations, the real problem shows up. People don't know where they are on the list. A simple fix: post the list (first names and numbers only) on the garden gate and on a shared page, updated each month. No app needed.

The best design choice is sometimes no new design at all.

Dark patterns: design that tricks people

A dark pattern is a design choice that pushes people to do something they did not mean to do. Here are common ones:

Dark patternWhat it looks likeWhy it harms
Confirm-shaming"No thanks, I don't care about my health"Uses guilt to push a choice
Hidden opt-outA pre-checked box to share your dataPeople share data they never agreed to share
Roach motelEasy to sign up, very hard to cancelTraps people
Fake urgency"Only 2 spots left!" when it isn't truePushes rushed choices with false facts

At Community Incubator, we don't design these. Not for a partner. Not for a grade. If a partner asks for one, say no and explain the harm.

Extra care for young people

If your design is for youth, the stakes go up. Kids and teens are easier to trick. Their data needs more protection. In the United States, a law called COPPA limits what apps can collect from children under 13. Collect as little as you can. Ask for a parent or guardian's consent.

Quiz: Spot the problem

  1. 01A sign-up form has a pre-checked box that says 'Share my info with partners.' What is this?

    Choose one.

  2. 02A pantry has long lines because there are not enough volunteers. Which is the best first step?

    Choose one.

Reflection

Private. Saved only in this browser. No one else can see it.

Go deeper: Product Management: Building the Right Thing, a Temerarii Media playbook.